After a successful run at Chichester Festival Theatre, Hugh Bonneville reprises his role as C.S. Lewis in the touching stage adaptation of Shadowlands at the Aldwych Theatre, forcing the audience to face their preconceptions about God.
Shadowlands tells the story of C.S. Lewis' (often referred to as Jack) battle with his faith, as he struggles to come to terms with God's true intentions. This inner battle is further complicated when he meets Joy (Maggie Siff), an eager fan of his work, as the two of them form an unlikely relationship that is hit by a major setback. A word that perfectly describes the feel of the production is charming, from the sweet interactions Jack and Joy share with each other to the classical music (music by Catherine Jayes) used to underscore changes in location. William Nicholson's book is intelligent, with Jack's inner life often being shared with us through his teaching lectures that simultaneously break the fourth wall. Much of Jack and Joy's conversations are littered with their nerdy literary observations that endear the characters well to the audience.
Even though the first act can feel inactive at times, I am always engaged in the production, as the slow burn of Jack and Joy's relationship blossoming is just so captivating to watch. Without spoiling anything, the second act certainly shifts in tone and cuts much deeper. Much of it is emotional and affecting, although it feels quite fragmented at times, with too many set changes that interrupt our connection with the characters.
That being said, Rachel Kavanaugh's direction is certainly a highlight of this production, with the scene transitions looking so elegant that they feel like ballet dancing at times, as one actor dresses another while the scene begins. Peter McKintosh's set design captures the rustic feel of Jack's home, and the rotating set often helps give the impression of time progressing.
Hugh Bonneville is incredibly earnest in this role, showing so much modesty when he ought to be much more proud, which hurts us so much more when we see him in pain. Maggie Siff is equally delightful, nailing the odd quirks of Joy whilst remaining endearing to us and providing a formidable sparring partner, friend and lover to Jack. The collection of men surrounding Jack are hilarious, with a highlight being Jack's brother, Major W.H. Lewis, played by the bumbling Jeff Rawle.
This is a heartfelt story about an iconic writer. Even though I would enjoy some more exploration into the worlds he creates and some more space given to the heavy emotional scenes, this is a deeply engaging watch.
It runs until 9 May. Tickets: here.
Review: James Simons Photos: Johan Persson